Government Outlaws Islam, Liberal Atheists Applaud

In a piece entitled “Nation Bans Minors From Entering Mosques,” the Huffington Post has reported that the authoritarian secular government of Tajikstan has outlawed minors from entering Islamic mosques, and requires everyone under 18 to attend secular school.  The crackdown on Islam is a not-subtle attempt to destroy his chief rivals, the Islamic Revival Party.

Having only seen the headline, I wasn’t initially sure which country had clamped down so fiercely on freedom of religion.  Given this, I had certain expectations about how the article – and the comments – would read.  Certainly, if it were some Western European country which had effectively outlawed the Muslim religion, the Huffington Post reaction would have been that this demonstrates how dangerous the religious right and the Tea Party are.  That if it could happen there, it could happen here — you can imagine how they would’ve gone.  But instead of some historically-Christian county, it was an authoritarian central Asian country with a majority-Muslim population.

When I first read the article, here were the top five comments:

  1. Freedom from religion is a good thing.
  2. God will take this country down.The reason America is going down is because God was kicked out of the classroom,­so the children have gone wild and so have the adults.
  3. Lets just get rid of religion
  4. It seems to me, that this President is attempting to do a GOOD thing !!
  5. An excellent idea. Religion should be taught when the children are over 16. Only then they can judge if what they are taught makes any sense. You can brainwash small children. That can result in producing extremists­. You can believe in anything, but respect for those who think differentl­y must be part of any teachings.

That’s right.  Out of the five most recent comments, four of them (from four different users) were praising a totalitarian government for outlawing religion.

Significantly, none of them said, “Outlawing Islam is good.”  That’s the sort of comment the fringe-right would make, and be rightly denounced for by both the Huffington Post crowd, and sane conservatives — it’s base bigotry, it’s un-American, it violates the First Amendment, etc.  Instead, each of the four (as well as a shocking number of other commenters) said things to the effect that “Outlawing religion is good.” Wanting to outlaw every religion?  No problem, at least based on the reactions I’ve seen so far.

If you pretend that all religions are equally bad / stupid / violent (whether it’s the Catholics, the Quakers, or the Muslims),  you’re apparently not a bigot at all.  As I’ve mentioned before, Frank Beckwith was ahead of the curve in observing this growing atheistic authoritarianism, noting that  from the way the mainstream media treats New Atheists (compared to anti-Muslim conservatives), “one can only conclude that the difference between a bigot and a respected intellectual is that the former rejects one less belief than the latter.

Now, certainly, I’m not claiming that the random sampling of Huffington Post commenters are representative of every liberal.  Far from it.  But what I am saying is that the surprising number of “pro-trampling religion” comments shows a rising and troubling tide amongst atheists on the Left.


  1. Hey guys, great post. I was wondering if anyone who runs this blog has an email account where I can submit a question that I have been having some problems with. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!!

  2. I’ve followed your blog a couple months now; I think you write well and that your content is interesting.

    Can you please address the idea #5 regarding religion/16/brainwashing. It would be much appreciated. Thanks.

  3. Patrick: shoot me an e-mail at joseph[dot]heschmeyer[at], and I’ll get back with you as soon as I can.

    CLA: One of the basic responsibilities of a parent is to inculcate virtue. If parents can’t teach their kids right from wrong, who can? Even animals teach their young appropriate social ethics. Teaching religion is part and parcel of teaching right and wrong.

    It’s not brainwashing, since ultimately (upon reaching the age of maturity), the child will either accept or reject what his parents have told him is true. This is true of religion and all ethics. Certainly, I disagree with some of the beliefs my parents instilled in me, even though I remain close to the core virtues which they taught. Quite frankly, were it not for a pretty solid upbringing, I don’t know if I’d be Catholic today.

    I’d add only that there’s no such thing as a non-option. That is, if you act like God doesn’t exist, a kid picks up on that, too. So whatever you do sends a signal either pro- or anti-God and religion. Neither one is innately “brainwashing.” It’s more like good or bad “parenting.”

    God bless,


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *